In a paper delivered to the Aristotelian Society on 12 March 1956,[1] Walter Bryce Gallie (1912–1998) introduced the term essentially contested concept to facilitate an understanding of the different applications or interpretations of the sorts of abstract, qualitative, and evaluative notions[2]—such as "art", "philanthropy",[3] "power",[4]
and "social justice"—used in the domains of aesthetics, sustainable development, political philosophy, philosophy of history, and philosophy of religion.
Garver (1978) describes their use as follows:
The term essentially contested concepts gives a name to a problematic situation that many people recognize: that in certain kinds of talk there is a variety of meanings employed for key terms in an argument, and there is a feeling that dogmatism ("My answer is right and all others are wrong"), skepticism ("All answers are equally true (or false); everyone has a right to his own truth"), and eclecticism ("Each meaning gives a partial view so the more meanings the better") are none of them the appropriate attitude towards that variety of meanings.[5]
Essentially contested concepts involve widespread agreement on a concept (e.g., "fairness"), but not on the best realization thereof.[6] They are "concepts the proper use of which inevitably involves endless disputes about their proper uses on the part of their users",[7] and these disputes "cannot be settled by appeal to empirical evidence, linguistic usage, or the canons of logic alone".[8]
^Published immediately as Gallie (1956a); a later, slightly altered version appears in Gallie (1964).
^They are "evaluative" in the sense that they deliver some sort of "value-judgement".
^Daly (2012)
^
Dowding, Keith (February 2011). "Essentially Contested Concept". In Dowding, Keith (ed.). Encyclopedia of Power. Sage Reference. Los Angeles: SAGE (published 2011). pp. 221–222. ISBN 9781412927482. Retrieved 12 November 2021. Power is often described as an essentially contested concept. That term was first introduced into political theory in 1958 by [...] Gallie, who applies it to various subject-terms including power.
^Garver (1978), p. 168.
^Hart (1961, p. 156) speaks of "a uniform or constant feature", and "a shifting or varying criterion used in determining when, for any given purposes, cases are alike or different".
^Gallie (1956a), p. 169. The dispute is about the proper use of the concept; and all argue that the concept is being "used inappropriately" by others (Smith, 2002, p. 332).
^Gray (1977), p. 344.
and 24 Related for: Essentially contested concept information
“Essential Contestedness” of Political Concepts", Ethics, Vol.95, No. 4, (July 1985), pp. 811–827. Waldron, J., "Is the Rule of Law an EssentiallyContested Concept...
infrequently between simultaneously producing mathematicians." Essentiallycontestedconcept The equivalent idiom in Chinese is "chicken talking to a duck"...
policy and the freedom of the press, representing an "essentiallycontestedconcept". The concept is often used to denote, declare, or claim independence...
experiences and relationships. Home has been described as an "essentiallycontestedconcept". Common connotations of home are espoused by both those with...
is best understood as an essentiallycontestedconcept. As he argues, "it seems that it is this very nature of the concept that has allowed, on the one...
it is indeed hard to avoid the conclusion that Europe is an essentiallycontestedconcept." Cf. also Davies (1996:15); Berting (2006:51). Cf. Jordan-Bychkov...
Braman & Gastil (2006) Thompson, M. (2011) “Sustainability is an essentiallycontestedconcept”. S.A.P.I.EN.S. 4 (1) Boholm (2003), p. 66. Douglas (1986) Boholm...
definitions. List of fallacies Definition Dogwhistle politics Essentiallycontestedconcept Loaded language Poisoning the well Stipulative definition The...
of Aesthetics - Entertainment - Eroticism - Essentialism - Essentiallycontestedconcept - Fact-value distinction - Ferdinand Gotthelf Hand - Ferruccio...
Counterculture of the 1960s Economic justice Environmental racism Essentiallycontestedconcept Global justice Human trafficking Labour law and labour rights...
filter makes it possible to know only little but exactly. Essentiallycontestedconcept Fuzzy concept Unconstitutional vagueness Obfuscation Relevance Understanding...
argumentation Discourse ethics – Argument focused on ethics Essentiallycontestedconcept – Problem in philosophy Forensics – Application of science to...
Political Theory Vol. 5, No.2, May 2006. "Is Liberalism Now an EssentiallyContestedConcept?" New Political Science Vol. 27, No. 4, December 2005. "Recognizing...
it is indeed hard to avoid the conclusion that Europe is an essentiallycontestedconcept." Cf. also Davies (1996:15); Berting (2006:51). Cf. Jordan-Bychkov...
entire organizations. "Leadership" is a contested term. Specialist literature debates various viewpoints on the concept, sometimes contrasting Eastern and...
at Harvard University, Stanford University and other places. Essentiallycontestedconcept – Problem in philosophy Ethical calculus – Application of mathematics...
the region. Maritime terrorism, like terrorism itself, is an essentiallycontestedconcept. Because there are over 100 definitions of terrorism from multiple...
disagreements. Betrayal, Margalit says, is an essentiallycontestedconcept, "that is to say, in all its uses the concept of traitor is always subject to dispute...
so unhappy", as Stephen Dedalus called them – "power" is an "essentiallycontestedconcept", meaning that people with different values and beliefs are...
of Political Economy Essays, Moral, Political, and Literary Essentiallycontestedconcept Ethic of reciprocity Ethical arguments regarding torture Ethics...
Global Information