Coercive logic is a concept popularised by mathematician Raymond Smullyan, by which a person who has agreed to answer a question truthfully is forced to perform an undesired action, where not doing so would mean breaking their agreement.[1] Smullyan presents the concept as a question:
Suppose I offer you a million dollars to answer a yes/no question truthfully, would you accept the offer? If so, you shouldn't, for I would then ask: Will you either answer no to this question or pay me two million dollars? The only way you can answer truthfully is by answering yes and then paying me two million dollars.[2]
Smullyan's question is asking the reader whether at least one of the two options is true:[3]
They will truthfully answer no to his question.
They will pay him two million dollars.
The reader is unable to truthfully give an answer of no, as doing so would be to assert that both of the statements were false: "no, my answer is not no" and "no, I will not pay you two million dollars". The first of these is a self-contradictory statement.
If the reader answers yes, they cannot be saying that "will truthfully answer no" is true (as they did not answer no), so must be asserting that "will pay two million dollars" is true. Therefore, they must give Smullyan two million dollars.[3]
Smullyan credits the name of the process to his son-in-law Jack Kotik.[2]
^"The Bulletin of Symbolic Logic". Association for Symbolic Logic. 2009. Retrieved 3 March 2020. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
^ abSmullyan, Raymond M. (2012). The Riddle of Scheherazade: And Other Amazing Puzzles, Ancient and Modern. Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group. ISBN 978-0-307-81983-3. Retrieved 3 March 2020.
^ abRosenhouse, J. "Coercive Logic". scienceblogs.com. Retrieved 3 March 2020.
Coercivelogic is a concept popularised by mathematician Raymond Smullyan, by which a person who has agreed to answer a question truthfully is forced to...
Biography portal Philosophy portal Alice's Adventures in Wonderland Coercivelogic Paradox The Lady, or the Tiger J J O'Connor and E F Robertson (April...
Coercive deficiency is a phrase that originated in study of the executive branch of the American federal government, where it described the process by...
corissajoy (3 October 2016). "Summary of "The General Theory and Logic of Coercive Diplomacy"". Beyond Intractability. Retrieved 5 January 2023. Byman...
S2CID 145559042. Markwica, Robin (2018). Emotional Choices: How the Logic of Affect Shapes Coercive Diplomacy (First ed.). Oxford, OX. ISBN 978-0-19-251311-3....
Dustin (2019). "Roundtable on Emotional Choices: How the Logic of Affect Shapes Coercive Diplomacy, with an introduction by Robert Jervis" (PDF). H-Diplo...
mathematics is to be constructed. In computing, definitions can be used as logic programs In modern usage, a definition is something, typically expressed...
different airpower strategies. It questions the conventional wisdom that coercive air power (i.e. bombing, etc.) is both effective and relatively cheap....
alternative explanation of the "causal logic of suicide terrorism": at the strategic level, suicide terrorism exerts coercive power against democratic states...
transactions exemplified in financial economics. Luttwak argues that the same logic that underlies military conflict also pertains to international commerce:...
major category of mass killings, namely dispossessive mass killings and coercive mass killings. The first category includes ethnic cleansing, killings that...
Press. See Robin Markwica (2018), Emotional Choices: How the Logic of Affect Shapes Coercive Diplomacy. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Descartes, René...
2021-07-14 George, A (1991), "The General Theory and Logic of Coercive Diplomacy", Forceful Persuasion: Coercive Diplomacy as an Alternative to War, Washington...
Regime change is the partly forcible or coercive replacement of one government regime with another. Regime change may replace all or part of the state's...
value of type A also represents the same value at type B if A <: B, and coercive implementations, in which a value of type A can be automatically converted...
as a deprogrammer in the late 1970s, but since then has advocated a non-coercive form of exit counseling. Hassan has written several books on the subject...
detention of suspects incommunicado (b) without access to a lawyer (c) coercive interrogation to obtain evidence and (d) the use of "secret evidence"....
John R. P. French and Bertram Raven introduced the five bases of power: Coercive, Reward, Legitimate, Referent, and Expert. This was followed by Raven's...
approval and fear being outcast from their community. That lifestyle has a coercive effect, which compels people to abandon "inner-direction" of their lives...
commentators view its platform as unacceptably extreme, while endorsing the logic of reducing the rate of human reproduction. In response to VHEMT, some journalists...
origin, and range. In terms of content, not all laws are imperative or coercive. Some are facilitative, allowing us to create contracts and other legal...
175. Alfred W. McCoy (2012). Torture and Impunity: The U.S. Doctrine of Coercive Interrogation. University of Wisconsin Press. pp. 93–94. Mark Moyar (2007)...
system by which the public sector is funded, namely taxation, is itself coercive and unjust. However, even notable small-government proponents have pushed...
Global Information