This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages)
This article may be confusing or unclear to readers. Please help clarify the article. There might be a discussion about this on the talk page.(March 2016) (Learn how and when to remove this message)
This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed. Find sources: "Vicious circle principle" – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR(March 2016) (Learn how and when to remove this message)
(Learn how and when to remove this message)
The vicious circle principle is a principle that was endorsed by many predicativist mathematicians in the early 20th century to prevent contradictions. The principle states that no object or property may be introduced by a definition that depends on that object or property itself. In addition to ruling out definitions that are explicitly circular (like "an object has property P iff it is not next to anything that has property P"), this principle rules out definitions that quantify over domains which include the entity being defined. Thus, it blocks Russell's paradox, which defines a set R that contains all sets which do not contain themselves. This definition is blocked because it defines a new set in terms of the totality of all sets, of which this new set would itself be a member.
However, it also blocks one standard definition of the natural numbers. First, we define a property as being "hereditary" if, whenever a number n has the property, so does n +1. Then we say that x has the property of being a natural number if and only if it has every hereditary property that 0 has. This definition is blocked, because it defines "natural number" in terms of the totality of all hereditary properties, but "natural number" itself would be such a hereditary property, so the definition is circular in this sense.
Most modern mathematicians and philosophers of mathematics think that this particular definition is not circular in any problematic sense, and thus they reject the vicious circle principle. But it was endorsed by many early 20th-century researchers, including Bertrand Russell and Henri Poincaré. On the other hand, Frank P. Ramsey and Rudolf Carnap accepted the ban on explicit circularity, but argued against the ban on circular quantification. After all, the definition "let T be the tallest man in the room" defines T by means of quantification over a domain (men in the room) of which T is a member. But this is not problematic, they suggest, because the definition does not actually create the person, but merely shows how to pick him out of the totality. Similarly, they suggest, definitions do not actually create sets or properties or objects, but rather just give one way of picking out the already existing entity from the collection of which it is a part. Thus, this sort of circularity in terms of quantification cannot cause any problems.
This principle was the reason for Russell's development of the ramified theory of types rather than the theory of simple types. (See "Ramified Hierarchy and Impredicative Principles".[1])
An analysis of the paradoxes to be avoided shows that they all result from a kind of vicious circle. The vicious circles in question arise from supposing that a collection of objects may contain members which can only be defined by means of the collection as a whole. Thus, for example, the collection of propositions will be supposed to contain a proposition stating that “all propositions are either true or false.” It would seem, however, that such a statement could not be legitimate unless “all propositions” referred to some already definite collection, which it cannot do if new propositions are created by statements about “all propositions.” We shall, therefore, have to say that statements about “all propositions” are meaningless.… The principle which enables us to avoid illegitimate totalities may be stated as follows: “Whatever involves all of a collection must not be one of the collection”; or, conversely: “If, provided a certain collection had a total, it would have members only definable in terms of that total, then the said collection has no total.” We shall call this the “vicious-circle principle,” because it enables us to avoid the vicious circles involved in the assumption of illegitimate totalities. (Whitehead and Russell 1910, 37) (quoted in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on Russell's Paradox)
^"Ramified Hierarchy and Impredicative Principles". (section 3 of a web page that is an on-line article about Type Theory, in [part of] the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). Archived from the original on September 2, 2013. Retrieved July 15, 2013.
and 25 Related for: Vicious circle principle information
The viciouscircleprinciple is a principle that was endorsed by many predicativist mathematicians in the early 20th century to prevent contradictions...
class, the problem of impredicative definitions and Russell's "viciouscircleprinciple" below. Step 4: Assign a "numeral" to each bundle: For purposes...
Self-refuting idea Recursive definition Revision theory Tautology Viciouscircleprinciple "Circular Definition". Glossary of Linguistic Terms. 2015-12-03...
antinomies – a source of more fundamental nature than Russell's viciouscircleprinciple indicated. Brouwer opened our eyes and made us see how far classical...
predicativity, connecting it to current outstanding research problems. The viciouscircleprinciple was suggested by Henri Poincaré (1905–6, 1908) and Bertrand Russell...
difficulties which arise in formal logic", and Chap. 2.I. "The Vicious-CirclePrinciple" p. 37ff, and Chap. 2.VIII. "The Contradictions" p. 60ff. Martin...
difficulties which arise in formal logic", and Chap. 2.I. "The Vicious-CirclePrinciple" p. 37ff, and Chap. 2.VIII. "The Contradictions" p. 60 ff. The...
Chapter II: "The Theory of Logical Types" to subchapter I. The Vicious-CirclePrinciple: "We will define a function of one variable as predicative when...
rock scene, along with Black Flag, Circle Jerks and Bad Religion. Grisham has also fronted the bands ViciousCircle, the Joykiller, Tender Fury and Cathedral...
reprint of 2nd edition 1927, first edition 1913. Chap. 2.I. "The Vicious-CirclePrinciple" p. 37ff, and Chap. 2.VIII. "The Contradictions" p. 60ff. Turing...
Frank P. Ramsey noticed that, if one is willing to give up the viciouscircleprinciple, the hierarchy of levels of types in the "ramified theory of types"...
Valuation-based system -- Van Gogh fallacy -- Venn diagram -- Viciouscircleprinciple -- Warnier/Orr diagram -- Well-formed formula -- What the Tortoise...
statement, and is sometimes considered a nullary connective. viciouscircleprinciple A principle against definitions or arguments that are circular, ensuring...
go on to perpetuate the vicious cycle. At the failure of the ego to embrace its developing role within the reality principle, it remains under the control...
Capuzzo, Jill P. (25 November 2007). "A Shift, but for Some Drivers, a ViciousCircle". The New York Times. Retrieved 27 March 2010. Google. "Drum Hill Rotary"...
actually true. In this view, one opinion, proposed as a metaphysical principle in process philosophy, is that every cause and every effect is respectively...
to The Filth and the Fury, it was invented by Sex Pistols bassist Sid Vicious in 1976. As a prominent punk rock scene in Southern California began to...
unavoidable, then the game of morality is up. We are involved in a viciouscircle from which there is no escape except in the denial of one premiss [sic]...
The aggression grows and can result in self-destructive behavior. The viciouscircle can be broken by one agent stopping to react defensively and turn the...
drives further technological growth.: 146 Gunnar Myrdal described a viciouscircle of increasing inequalities, and poverty, which is known as circular...
proverbial Portuguese and Spanish expressions for circular reasoning and viciouscircles. The Kobe, Japan-based Dragon Gate Pro-Wrestling promotion used a stylised...
Navy Fort Parker massacre, at Parker's Fort, Texas Mrs. Parker and the ViciousCircle Parker, a player of park golf Parker (1984 film), a 1984 British crime...
monism, the doctrine that all of reality can be derived from a single principle, "the One". Neoplatonism began with Ammonius Saccas and his student Plotinus...
Global Information
