Trivial objections (also referred to as hair-splitting, nothing but objections, barrage of objections and banal objections) is an informal logical fallacy where irrelevant and sometimes frivolous objections are made to divert the attention away from the topic that is being discussed.[1][2] This type of argument is called a "quibble" or "quillet".[citation needed] Trivial objections are a special case of red herring.
The fallacy often appears when an argument is difficult to oppose. The person making a trivial objection may appear ready to accept the argument in question, but at the same time they will oppose it in many different ways.[1][2]: 165 These objections can appear in the form of lists, hypotheticals, and even accusations.
Such objections themselves may be valid, but they fail to confront the main argument under consideration. Instead, the objection opposes a small, irrelevant part of the main argument.[3] The fallacy is committed because of this diversion; it is fallacious to oppose a point on the basis of minor and incidental aspects, rather than responding to the main claim.
These objections are often used to not address the merit of an argument but rather to oppose them from a technicality.
Example:
Tom is using a barrage of objections:
Amy: Tomatoes are fruit, not vegetable.
Tom: Tomatoes can't be fruit. They don't grow on trees.
Amy: But pineapples also don't grow on trees and are fruit.
Tom: Tomatoes still can't be fruit. They are used in salads.
Amy: Apples are also used in salads and are fruit.
Tom: Tomatoes still can't be fruit. They are of botanical order Solanales.
(etc...)
^ abPirie, Madsen (12 Mar 2015). How to Win Every Argument. London: Bloomsbury. ISBN 9781472526977.
^ abMadsen Pirie (November 1985). The book of the fallacy: a training manual for intellectual subversives. Routledge & K. Paul. p. 164. ISBN 9780710205216.
^T. Edward Damer (21 February 2008). Attacking Faulty Reasoning: A Practical Guide to Fallacy-Free Arguments. Cengage Learning. p. 206. ISBN 978-0-495-09506-4.
and 25 Related for: Trivial objections information
Trivialobjections (also referred to as hair-splitting, nothing but objections, barrage of objections and banal objections) is an informal logical fallacy...
Tilting at windmills – Idiom meaning "attacking imaginary enemies" Trivialobjections – Fallacy in informal logic Downes, Stephen. "The Logical Fallacies"...
they are the same. Logic chopping fallacy (nit-picking, trivialobjections) – Focusing on trivial details of an argument, rather than the main point of...
Objections to evolution have been raised since evolutionary ideas came to prominence in the 19th century. When Charles Darwin published his 1859 book On...
A quibble may refer to: a trivialobjection a pun, or play on words Quibble (plot device), in narratology Quibble (computing), a quad nibble This disambiguation...
Id The Pettifogger, a 2011 film from Lewis Klahr Gaming the system Trivialobjections This disambiguation page lists articles associated with the title...
entrenched sexism and male dominance of the profession, its often trivialobjections to women entrants, and the uphill struggle of balancing family life...
advantageous adaptation without incurring "maladaptations". Consider a seemingly trivial example: it is apparently extremely hard for an animal to evolve the ability...
education, including Amusing Ourselves to Death (1985), Conscientious Objections (1988), Technopoly: The Surrender of Culture to Technology (1992), The...
is trivial. Examining another simple instance of the standard equivalence schema: Grass is green is true if and only if grass is green. the objection is...
simplicity conditions to obtain a path integral for general relativity. The non-trivial task of constructing a spin foam model is then reduced to the question...
to the Russian Democratic Union and invade and annex Georgia over the objections of the international community. After the RDU invades the Baltic States...
sometimes leading to materialism, or by arguing that relativism is trivial. A third objection that coherentism faces is the problem of isolation. Intuitively...
But in 1916, the astrophysicist Karl Schwarzschild found the first non-trivial exact solution to the Einstein field equations, the Schwarzschild metric...
observed that well-crafted tweets by public figures often deliberately mix trivial and serious information so as to appeal to all three parts of the reader's...
Jack; Witcover, Jules (1989). Whose Broad Stripes and Bright Stars? The Trivial Pursuit of the Presidency 1988. Warner Books. ISBN 978-0-446-51424-8. Smith...
Spider convertible. Also, Chumlee organizes a Christmas party, over the objections of the Old Man, who feels the shop's expansion has made the annual event...
the malicious intent inherent in the commission of any crime, however trivial, was considered to apply to any consequences of that crime regardless of...
Zebaish (2020). The script was written by Fakhra Jabeen which had the trivial portrayal of marital rape. On Hocane's account, the script was altered...
high-heel pumps. Of course, everyone now loved her and actually fought to do trivial favors for her such as walking her home. When Gargamel made contact with...
UltraSurf was awarded $1.8 million in funding under Pack, despite the objections of several high-ranking officials who were subsequently fired. Pack's...
walked the ramps of Lakme Fashion Week and performed in a play called Trivial Disasters. In January 2020, the actress had expressed solidarity with the...
watchdog rejects all complaints about Rayner Mail article after 6000 objections". Independent.co.uk. 4 May 2022. Ambrose, Tom (27 April 2022). "Mail on...
Global Information