Global InformationLegal assessments of the Gaza flotilla raid information
Many legal assessments of the Gaza flotilla raid were published subsequent to the event. International law experts (and non-lawyers) differed over the legality of the action by Israel. The force necessary to respond to violent resistance and whether the force that was used was proportionate were disputed.[1][2]
Approximately one year after the event, the UN investigative committee for the 2010 Flotilla to Gaza concluded that (1) the blockade was legal, based on the principle of self-defense, (2) Israel was "justified in stopping vessels even outside its territorial waters," (3) Israel's decision to board the vessels with such force was "excessive," (4) Israeli forces "faced significant, organized and violent resistance from a group of passengers" that required them to use force for their own protection, and (5) the loss of nine lives was "unacceptable."[3][4] It recommended that Israel immediately report its use of force to the United Nations Security Council for resolution as specified in Chapter VII of the United Nations Charter.
Some, such as law experts Harvard Law School Professor Alan Dershowitz, Chicago Law School Professor Eric Posner, and Johns Hopkins International Law and Diplomacy Professor Ruth Wedgwood, said that the naval blockade, the boarding in international waters, and the use of force were in accord with long-standing international law.[5][6][7] Dershowitz compared the blockade with the U.S. blockade of Cuba during the Cuban Missile Crisis and Posner with the Coalition blockade of Iraq during the first Gulf War.[5][6][7]
The United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, the International Committee of the Red Cross, the National Lawyers Guild's International Committee, Istanbul Bilgi University's Law Department Dean Turgut Tarhanlı and other experts have concluded that the blockade was itself illegal, or agreed with University of Dundee international law professor Robin Churchill that the boarding on the high seas was illegal even if the blockade were lawful, or agreed with international law professor Said Mahmoudi that the use of force was disproportionate and the raid was therefore illegal even if the blockade and the boarding in international waters were lawful.[8][9][10][11] An investigation by a panel of legal experts convened by the UN determined that the use of force by the Israeli military was disproportionate, that the Israeli military violated international law, and found clear evidence sufficient for war crimes prosecutions under the Fourth Geneva Convention - which defines humanitarian protections for civilians in a war zone and prohibits total war.[12]
The issue of possible violation of international law was discussed at the UN Security Council. The United States blocked a draft resolution criticizing Israel proposed by Turkey, the Palestinians, and Arab nations.[13]
- ^ Colum Lynch (June 1, 2010). "Israel's flotilla raid revives questions of international law". The Washington Post. Retrieved June 2, 2010.
scholars on both sides of the debate agree that Israel is required by law to respond with the proportional use of force in the face of violent resistance
- ^ Hirsch, Afua (June 1, 2010). "Was the Gaza Flotilla Raid Illegal?". The Guardian. London: Guardian News and Media. Retrieved June 2, 2010.
- ^ Mark Weiss (7 July 2011). "Israel sea blockade of Gaza legal, but attack on Mavi Marmara was 'excessive'". Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 27 March 2015.
- ^ "Israel used excessive force on Gaza flotilla - GlobalPost.com". Archived from the original on 2011-09-02.
- ^ a b Cite error: The named reference
nydailynews1was invoked but never defined (see the help page). - ^ a b Cite error: The named reference
autogenerated1was invoked but never defined (see the help page). - ^ a b Cite error: The named reference
autogenerated2was invoked but never defined (see the help page). - ^ Ben Saul. "Israel's Security Cannot Come at Any Price - Legal Analysis of Flotilla Attack". Archived from the original on July 27, 2011. Retrieved June 10, 2010.
- ^ "Conference Program" (PDF). Retrieved June 4, 2010.
- ^ Teibel, Amy; Tia Goldenberg (May 31, 2010). "Israeli police say 16 Gaza activists sent to jail". Associated Press.[dead link]
- ^ Karoline Hoppe (May 31, 2010). "Folkrättsprofessorn: Israel har brutit mot internationell rätt" (in Swedish). DN. Archived from the original on May 25, 2012. Retrieved June 4, 2010.
- ^ "Israeli raid on Gaza aid flotilla broke law - UN probe". BBC. 22 September 2010. Retrieved 22 September 2010.
- ^ McGreal, Chris (June 1, 2010). "Israel should lead investigation into attack on Gaza flotilla, says US". The Guardian. London: Guardian News and Media. Retrieved June 2, 2010.