Immanent critique is a method of analyzing culture that identifies contradictions in society's rules and systems. Most importantly, it juxtaposes the ideals articulated by society against the inadequate realization of those ideals in society's institutions.
As a method for the critique of ideology, immanent critique analyzes cultural forms in philosophy, the social sciences and humanities. Immanent critique pays close attention to the logic and meanings of the ideas expressed in the cultural text. It further aims to contextualize not only the specific cultural object of its investigation, but also the broader ideological basis of that text: It aims to show that the ideology is a product of a historical process and does not reflect timeless truths.
Immanent critique has its roots in the dialectic of Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel and the criticisms of both Pierre-Joseph Proudhon and Karl Marx. Today it is strongly associated with the critical theorists such as Theodor Adorno as well as literary theorists such as Fredric Jameson who, in his foundational work The Political Unconscious, explored the idea of an immanent analysis of texts to argue the primacy of political interpretation. Roy Bhaskar has advocated it as one of the key methodological elements of critical realism.[1]
Adorno contrasted immanent critique with "transcendent" critique, which typically reduces a set of ideas to their political uses or to the class interests they express. Transcendent critique, unlike immanent critique, adopts an external perspective and focuses on the historical genesis of ideas, while negating the values expressed in the cultural text.[2]
The purpose of immanent critique, instead, is the detection of societal contradictions that suggest possibilities for emancipatory social change. It considers the role of ideas in shaping society. An immanent critique of a cultural text discusses the ideal principles (overt or implicit) proposed by the text. It highlights the gaps between what something stands for and what is actually being done in society. Immanent critique tries to find contradictions in the internal logic of the cultural text and indirectly provide alternatives, without constructing an entirely new theory. It has the power to appeal to people's shared ideals while highlighting how far society has to go before those ideals are realized.
Quoting Marx, Robert J. Antonio writes:
"'Setting out from idealism ... I hit upon seeking the Idea in the real itself. If formerly the gods had dwelt above the world, they had now become its center.' Marx concluded that immanent principles were necessary weapons in the struggle for progressive social change, because they provide a basis for critique within historical reality. Later, this immanent grounding became the axis of his emancipatory critique of capitalism."[3]
According to David L. Harvey:
"Critical theory at its most abstract and general level ... begins as a formal 'negativity.' As a dissenting motif, it selects some tradition, ideological premise, or institutionalized orthodoxy for analysis. As immanent critique, it then 'enters its object,' so to speak, 'boring from within.' Provisionally accepting the methodological presuppositions, substantive premises, and truth-claims of orthodoxy as its own, immanent critique tests the postulates of orthodoxy by the latter's own standards of proof and accuracy. Upon 'entering' the theory, orthodoxy's premises and assertions are registered and certain strategic contradictions located. These contradictions are then developed according to their own logic, and at some point in this process of internal expansion, the one-sided proclamations of orthodoxy collapse as material instances and their contradictions are allowed to develop 'naturally.'"[4]
^Bhaskar, R. (2008) [1975], A Realist Theory of Science (Routledge 'With a new introduction' edition), Abingdon: Routledge.
^Adorno, T. (1982), Prisms, MIT Press: Cambridge.
^"Immanent critique as the core of critical theory." British Journal of Sociology Vol. 32, No. 3, p. 333 (1981)
Immanentcritique is a method of analyzing culture that identifies contradictions in society's rules and systems. Most importantly, it juxtaposes the...
or Aristotelian tradition. Kant's "transcendental" critique can be contrasted to Hegel's "immanent dialectics." Thomas Carlyle's idea of "Natural Supernaturalism"...
They held that culture must be studied using the Hegelian concept of immanentcritique: the theory that adequate description and criticism of a philosophical...
from which to critique or resist. The potential for political action nonetheless remains, but requires strategies of "immanentcritique" that counter-modulate...
its own espoused values (i.e. immanentcritique). Significantly, critical theory not only conceptualizes and critiques societal power structures, but...
Ignoramus et ignorabimus Ignorance I know that I know nothing Immanence Immanentcritique Implicate and explicate order Inductive reasoning Infallibility Inference...
liberatory, may become ideological as time goes on. Binary opposition Immanentcritique Interpellation "Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses" Louis...
soundness of the methodology used in producing the book, which is called immanentcritique. This approach, which starts from simple category and gradually unfolds...
thereby have renounced the only means of developing a consistent and immanentcritique of modernity itself. Modernity is defined by Habermas as a set of...
notion of immanentcritique. In contrast to a 'transcendent critique' that critiques other theories from outside its own principles, immanentcritique unfolds...
depends. A major example of this type of argument is said to be that of immanentcritique, although it is not the only kind. In deductive arguments, the "test"...
Dooyeweerd. Though he did not label it "posthumanism", he made an immanentcritique of humanism, and then constructed a philosophy that presupposed neither...
that the raison d'être of classic liberal feminism was "to pose an immanentcritique of liberalism, revealing the gendered exclusions within liberal democracy's...
engagement with the traditions of American pragmatism and continental immanentcritique and grounded in the circulation of values, materialities, and socialities...
conjunction of events perceived". Bhaskar develops what he calls an immanentcritique of empiricism in which he takes some of its core assumptions as correct...
both immanent and transcendental critiques of Western philosophy, following the traditions of Continental philosophy. In his immanentcritique, he sought...
member of Lotta Femminista, Dalla Costa, developed this analysis as an immanentcritique of Italian Workerism. She was a co-founder of the International Feminist...
Contrary to the Young Hegelians, Stirner scorned all attempts at an immanentcritique of Hegel and the Enlightenment and renounced Bauer and Feuerbach's...
might engage one another rationally – most especially via a form of immanentcritique which makes use of empathetic imagination to then put the rival tradition...
Grundrisse Marx concludes that adequate critical theory must be completely immanent to its purpose. The criticism cannot be taken from a point of view external...
attempt to counter the philosophical doctrine of skepticism, he wrote the Critique of Pure Reason (1781/1787), his best-known work. Kant drew a parallel to...
that the raison d'être of classic liberal feminism was "to pose an immanentcritique of liberalism, revealing the gendered exclusions within liberal democracy’s...
1007/978-1-349-16763-0_12. ISBN 978-0-333-27551-1. Arato, Andrew (1983). "ImmanentCritique and Authoritarian Socialism". Canadian Journal of Political and Social...
Global Information