Ethics of quantification is the study of the ethical issues associated to different forms of visible or invisible forms of quantification. These could include algorithms, metrics/indicators, statistical and mathematical modelling, as noted in a review of various aspects of sociology of quantification.[1]
According to Espeland and Stevens[2] an ethics of quantification would naturally descend from a sociology of quantification, especially at an age where democracy, merit, participation, accountability and even ‘‘fairness’’ are assumed to be best discovered and appreciated via numbers. In his classic work Trust in Numbers Theodore M. Porter[3] notes how numbers meet a demand for quantified objectivity, and may for this be by used by bureaucracies or institutions to gain legitimacy and epistemic authority.
For Andy Stirling of the STEPS Centre at Sussex University there is a rhetoric element around concepts such as ‘expected utility’, ‘decision theory’, ‘life cycle assessment’, ‘ecosystem services’ ‘sound scientific decisions’ and ‘evidence-based policy’. The instrumental application of these techniques and their use of quantification to deliver an impression of accuracy may raise ethical concerns.[4]
For Sheila Jasanoff these technologies of quantification can be labeled as 'Technologies of hubris',[5] whose function is to reassure the public while keeping the wheels of science and industry turning. The downside of the technologies of hubris is that they may generate overconfidence thanks to the appearance of exhaustivity; they can preempt a political discussion by transforming a political problem into a technical one; and remain fundamentally limited in processing what takes place outside their restricted range of assumptions.
Jasanoff contrasts technologies of hubris with 'technologies of humility'[6] which admit the existence of ambiguity, indeterminacy and complexity, and strive to bring to the surface the ethical nature of problems. Technologies of humility are also sensitive to the need to alleviate known causes of people’s vulnerability, to pay attention to the distribution of benefits and risks, and to identify those factors and strategies which may promote or inhibit social learning.
For Sally Engle Merry, studying indicators of human rights, gender violence and sex trafficking, quantification is a technology of control, but whether it is reformist or authoritarian depends on who has harnessed its power and for what purpose. She notes in order to make indicators less misleading and distorting some principles should be followed:[7]
democratize the production of indicators
develop in parallel qualitative research to verify the validity of assumptions
keep it the indicators simple
test or adopt multiple framings
admit the limits of the various measures
The field of algorithms and artificial intelligence is the regime of quantification where the discussion about ethics, is more advanced, see e.g. Weapons of Math Destruction[8] of Cathy O'Neil. While objectivity and efficiency are some positive properties associated with the use of algorithms, ethical issues are posed by these tools coming in the form of black boxes.[9] Thus algorithms have the power to act upon data and make decisions, but they are to a large extent beyond query.[8][10] The existence of a surveillance capitalism in the theme of Shoshana Zuboff[11] 2019 book. A more militant reading of the dangers posed by artificial intelligence is Resisting AI: An Anti-fascist Approach to Artificial Intelligence by Dan McQuillan.[12]
^E. Popp Berman and D. Hirschman, “The Sociology of Quantification: Where Are We Now?,” Contemp. Sociol., vol. 47, no. 3, pp. 257–266, 2018.
^W. N. Espeland and M. L. Stevens, “A sociology of quantification,” Eur. J. Sociol., vol. 49, no. 3, pp. 401–436, 2008.
^T. M. Porter, Trust in Numbers: The Pursuit of Objectivity in Science and Public Life. Princeton University Press, 1995.
^A. Stirling, “How politics closes down uncertainty - STEPS Centre,” STEPS Centre, 2019.
^Jasanoff, S. Technologies of humility: Citizen participation in governing science. Minerva 41, 223–244 (2003).
^Jasanoff, S. Technologies of humility. Nature 450, 33 (2007).
^S. Engle Merry, The Seductions of Quantification: Measuring Human Rights, Gender Violence, and Sex Trafficking. University of Chicago Press, 2016.
^ abC. O’Neil, Weapons of math destruction : how big data increases inequality and threatens democracy. Random House Publishing Group, 2016.
^J. Danaher et al., “Algorithmic governance: Developing a research agenda through the power of collective intelligence,” Big Data Soc., vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 1–21, 2017.
^R. Kitchin, “Thinking critically about and researching algorithms,” Inf. Commun. Soc., vol. 20, no. 1, pp. 14–29, Jan. 2017.
^Zuboff, Shoshana (January 2019). "Surveillance Capitalism and the Challenge of Collective Action". New Labor Forum. 28 (1): 10–29. doi:10.1177/1095796018819461. ISSN 1095-7960. S2CID 159380755.
^McQuillan, D. (2022). Resisting AI: An Anti-fascist Approach to Artificial Intelligence, Bristol University Press, https://bristoluniversitypress.co.uk/resisting-ai.
and 29 Related for: Ethics of quantification information
regarded as a form of dynamic moral absolutism. Ethical calculus is not to be confused with ethics in mathematics or ethicsofquantification which study the...
Unforeseen outcomes of an action Big data ethics – Ethicsof mass data analytics Ethicsofquantification - EthicsofquantificationEthicsof artificial intelligence...
Italian scholar specializing in quantification using statistical and sociological tools. He has extended the theory of sensitivity analysis to sensitivity...
sociology ofquantification is an expanding field which includes the literature on the quantified self, on algorithms, and on various forms of metrics and...
Palgrave Macmillan Sociology ofquantificationEthicsofquantification Porter, T. M. (1995). Trust in Numbers: The Pursuit of Objectivity in Science and...
Economic ethics is the combination of economics and ethics that uses judgements from both disciplines to predict, analyze, and model economic phenomena...
category of teleological ethics, a group of views which claim that the moral value of any act consists in its tendency to produce things of intrinsic...
extrinsic meaning, quantification is unavailing." (p. 62.) Hirschfeld RM, Lewis L, Vornik LA (February 2003). "Perceptions and impact of bipolar disorder:...
the unity of aesthetics and ethics is in fact reflected in our understanding of behaviour being "fair"—the word having a double meaning of attractive...
members of society the opportunity to act against their oppression by making injustice visible. Sociology ofquantificationEthicsofquantification Society...
welfare economics, questions of justice, the crisis of global poverty, the ethicsof raising animals for food, and the importance of avoiding existential risks...
uncertainty quantification. These belief function approaches that are implemented within the machine learning domain typically leverage a fusion approach of various...
German Ethics Council (German: Deutscher Ethikrat) (Precursor from June 2001 to February 2008: National Ethics Council of Germany) is an independent council...
The amount of water inflow is one of the inputs of the classification scheme, representing the groundwater condition. Quantificationof the water inflow...
opinions and right of free expression. Other than the ethics put in place in the United States of America there are also International ethics set to ensure...
introducing new forms ofquantification. Quantifiers correspond to terms like "all" or "some". In classical first-order logic, quantifiers are only applied...
diversity is difficult to quantify. One measure of diversity is the number of identifiable cultures. The United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs...
other members of the artificial intelligence research community, a status the author later said he'd come to take pride in. Ethicsof artificial intelligence...
may make decisions "like a robot" without considering ethics or the long-term consequences of their actions. Conversely, if PF is excessive, then the...
quantification fallacy is an error in logic where the quantifiersof the premises are in contradiction to the quantifierof the conclusion. Types of quantification...
Retrieved 10 September 2023. Pearce, Joshua M.; Parncutt, Richard (2023). "Quantifying Global Greenhouse Gas Emissions in Human Deaths to Guide Energy Policy"...
the confluence of elements of Aristotelian Ethics with Stoic psychology, led in the 1st–3rd centuries CE in the works of Alexander of Aphrodisias to the...
[needs update] Atheist organizations have defended the autonomy of science, secular ethics and secularism. Arguments for atheism range from philosophical...
Quine, referring to the problem of non-existent entities and their properties. plural quantificationQuantification over multiple objects or entities...
and Its Relation to Quantification Casati & Fujikawa, §1. Existence as a Second-Order Property and Its Relation to Quantification Lowe 2005, Existence...
were developed including: Cyanidin quantification by naphthalimide-based azo dye colorimetric probe. Lead quantification by modified immunoassay test strip...
of GDP versus HDI, it is often forgotten that these are both external indicators that prioritize different benchmarks upon which the quantification of...
Global Information