The argument from poor design, also known as the dysteleological argument, is an argument against the assumption of the existence of a creator God, based on the reasoning that any omnipotent and omnibenevolent deity or deities would not create organisms with the perceived suboptimal designs that occur in nature.
The argument is structured as a basic modus ponens: if "creation" contains many defects, then design appears an implausible theory for the origin of earthly existence. Proponents most commonly use the argument in a weaker way, however: not with the aim of disproving the existence of God, but rather as a reductio ad absurdum of the well-known argument from design (which suggests that living things appear too well-designed to have originated by chance, and so an intelligent God or gods must have deliberately created them).
Although the phrase "argument from poor design" has seen little use, this type of argument has been advanced many times using words and phrases such as "poor design", "suboptimal design", "unintelligent design" or "dysteleology/dysteleological". The nineteenth-century biologist Ernst Haeckel applied the term "dysteleology" to the implications of organs so rudimentary as to be useless to the life of an organism.[1] In his 1868 book Natürliche Schöpfungsgeschichte (The History of Creation), Haeckel devoted most of a chapter to the argument, ending with the proposition (perhaps with tongue slightly in cheek) of "a theory of the unsuitability of parts in organisms, as a counter-hypothesis to the old popular doctrine of the suitability of parts".[1] In 2005, Donald Wise of the University of Massachusetts Amherst popularised the term "incompetent design" (a play on "intelligent design"), to describe aspects of nature seen as flawed in design.[2]
Traditional Christian theological responses generally posit that God constructed a perfect universe but that humanity's misuse of its free will to rebel against God has resulted in the corruption of divine good design.[3][4][5]
^ abHaeckel, Ernst (1892). The History of Creation. Appleton, New York: D. Appleton. p. 331.
^Wise, Donald (2005-07-22). ""Intelligent" Design versus Evolution". Science. 309 (5734). AAAS: 556–557. doi:10.1126/science.309.5734.556c. PMID 16040688. S2CID 5241402.
^Harry Hahne, The Corruption and Redemption of Creation: Nature in Romans 8, Volume 34
^Gregory A. Boyd, God at War: The Bible & Spiritual Conflict
^
ed. Charles Taliaferro, Chad Meister, The Cambridge Companion to Christian Philosophical Theology, pages 160-161 - "Fundamental to the position is Augustine's view that the universe God created is good; everything in the universe is good and has good purpose [...]. [...] How did evil arise? It came about, he maintains, through free will. [...] some of God's free creatures turned their will from God, the supreme Good, to lesser goods. [...] It happened first with the angels and then [...] with humans. This is how moral evil entered the universe and this moral fall, or sin, also brought with it tragic cosmic consequences, for it ushered in natural evil as well."
and 28 Related for: Argument from poor design information
The argumentfrompoordesign, also known as the dysteleological argument, is an argument against the assumption of the existence of a creator God, based...
teleological argument (from τέλος, telos, 'end, aim, goal'; also known as physico-theological argument, argumentfromdesign, or intelligent designargument) is...
suffering. The theist responses are called theodicies. Similarly, the argumentfrompoordesign contends that an all-powerful, benevolent creator god would not...
The argumentfrom miracles is an argument for the existence of God that relies on the belief that events witnessed and described as miracles – i.e. as...
A cosmological argument, in natural theology, is an argument which claims that the existence of God can be inferred from facts concerning causation, explanation...
An argumentfrom nonbelief is a philosophical argument that asserts an inconsistency between the existence of God and a world in which people fail to...
from purposeful design. Ernst Haeckel (1834-1919) invented and popularized the term dysteleology (German: Dysteleologie). Adevism Argumentfrompoor design...
The argumentfrom free will, also called the paradox of free will or theological fatalism, contends that omniscience and free will are incompatible and...
The argumentfrom reason is a transcendental argument against metaphysical naturalism and for the existence of God (or at least a supernatural being that...
The argumentfrom morality is an argument for the existence of God. Argumentsfrom morality tend to be based on moral normativity or moral order. Arguments...
The argumentfrom consciousness is an argument for the existence of God that claims characteristics of human consciousness (such as qualia) cannot be explained...
The argumentfrom love is an argument for the existence of God that suggests the depth, complexity, and universality of love point to a transcendent source...
The argumentfrom degrees, also known as the degrees of perfection argument or the henological argument is an argument for the existence of God first proposed...
The argumentfrom beauty (also the aesthetic argument) is an argument for the existence of a realm of immaterial ideas or, most commonly, for the existence...
The argumentfrom desire is an argument for the existence of the immortality of the soul. The best-known defender of the argument is the Christian writer...
The argumentfrom religious experience is an argument for the existence of God. It holds that the best explanation for religious experiences is that they...
three main threads; the argumentfrom the wisdom of Jesus, the argumentfrom the claims of Jesus as son of God and the argumentfrom the resurrection.[citation...
ontological argument is a philosophical argument, made from an ontological basis, that is advanced in support of the existence of God. Such arguments tend to...
gods. Argumentfrompoordesign – reasons that an omnipotent, omniscient, omnibenevolent creator God would create organisms that have optimal design. Organisms...
prominent role in natural theology and the "argumentfromdesign," where it was used to support arguments for the existence of God of the universe, in...
way it ought to work". Plantinga explains his argument for proper function with reference to a "design plan", as well as an environment in which one's...
Intelligent design (ID) is a pseudoscientific argument for the existence of God, presented by its proponents as "an evidence-based scientific theory about...
problem of evil and the evidential problem of evil. The logical form of the argument tries to show a logical impossibility in the coexistence of a god and evil...
free market for labour required greater state intervention in poor relief. Bentham's argument that people chose pleasant options and would not do what was...
The Transcendental Argument for the existence of God (TAG) is a transcendental argument that attempts to prove the existence of God, i. e. it attempts...
designed by committee, which was largely designed based on feedback from extensive focus group testing, and was released to negative reviews and poor...
tested the old poor law to the breaking point. The 1601 Act states that each individual parish was responsible for its 'own' poor. Arguments over which parish...
Global Information
