Unfilmability is a type of medium specificity which prevents a work of literature from undergoing successful film or television adaptation. A wide variety of considerations can lead to a work being seen as unfilmable. These include aesthetic conventions, audience expectations, technological limitations and ethical or political considerations.[1]
In his Theory of the Film, Béla Balázs discussed (but ultimately rejected) a theoretical argument against adaptation, based on the idea that if there is "an organic connection between form and content in every art" then it must be concluded that "one may perhaps make a good film out of a bad novel, but never out of a good one".[2]
With the rise of prestigious and well-funded TV series in what is considered a Golden Age of Television in the 21st century, some works previously considered unfilmable have undergone visual adaptations.[3] Among works long considered unfilmable that have ultimately been successfully filmed are The Lord of the Rings,[4]Dune,[5]Watchmen,[6]Gerald's Game, and American Psycho.[7]
^Elliott, Kamilla (2017). "Unfilmable Books". In Grossman, Julie; Palmer, R. Barton (eds.). Adaptation in Visual Culture. Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 101–103. ISBN 978-3-319-58579-6.
^Balázs, Béla (1952). Theory of the Film. London: Denis Dobson. p. 259.
^Cain, Sian (July 3, 2019). "The Sandman, Catch-22, Cloud Atlas ... is there such thing as an 'unfilmable' book?". The Guardian.
^Drout 2006, p. 15 harvnb error: no target: CITEREFDrout2006 (help)
^"Why Filmmakers From David Lynch to Denis Villeneuve Have Struggled to Adapt Dune". TIME. 2021-10-20. Retrieved 2024-03-10.
^"Python Won’t Bite For Watchmen". EmpireOnline.com. November 13, 2000. Retrieved on October 18, 2008. Archived August 14, 2011, at the Wayback Machine
^"How director Mike Flanagan made Stephen King's 'unfilmable' book into a film". The Independent. 28 September 2017.
Unfilmability is a type of medium specificity which prevents a work of literature from undergoing successful film or television adaptation. A wide variety...
wanted to adapt the series as a feature film. Martin, however, deemed it "unfilmable", saying that the size of one of his novels is as long as The Lord of...
Kaufman. Kaufman said in 2016 that the novel was being written so as to be unfilmable, and is itself about "an impossible movie." Neurotic failed film critic...
William S. Burroughs' most controversial book. The novel was considered "unfilmable", and Cronenberg acknowledged that a straight translation into film would...
considered adapting Tolkien's book, among them Stanley Kubrick, who thought it unfilmable, Michelangelo Antonioni, Jim Henson, Heinz Edelmann, and John Boorman...
sense. Someone's dead and then they're alive. It's too long, violent, and unfilmable.' ... So I thought, 'That's that!'" Bender brought the script to Miramax...
Buscemi as Aldolfo Rollo, a self-conscious screenwriter who has written an unfilmable 500-page screenplay and who is looking for a producer. Tortured by self-doubt...
of Dunces: Stephen Fry on his decades-long struggle to adapt the most unfilmable book ever written". The Daily Telegraph. London, England. Archived from...
abandoned the project because he decided that Watchmen would have been unfilmable. "Reducing [the story] to a two or two-and-a-half hour film [...] seemed...
polarized response, with many critics contending that Faulkner's works are "unfilmable". Faulkner's final work, The Reivers, was adapted into a 1969 film starring...
Winterbottom's A Cock and Bull Story, a self-referential film of the "unfilmable" self-referential novel Tristram Shandy by Laurence Sterne. In the film...
development or pre-production stages. A common perception is that the story is "unfilmable" due to its unrelenting violence and dark tone. In an interview with The...
Retrieved 26 July 2014. Ford, Matt (11 September 2013). "Irvine Welsh: The 'unfilmable' Filth finally makes it to the big screen". The Independent. Independent...
Carolina: University of North Carolina Press: 16–31. JSTOR 20078027. "The unfilmable 'Blood Meridian'". The Conversation. March 11, 2018. Retrieved December...
4 March 2019. Armstrong, Neil (20 September 2021). "Foundation: The 'unfilmable' sci-fi epic now on our screens". bbc.com. Retrieved 25 September 2021...
the book was popular with the reading public, it had been considered unfilmable under the Hays Code because adultery was central to the plot. In 1945...
four and wrote that "127 Hours is like an exercise in conquering the unfilmable". Gazelle Emami wrote for The Huffington Post, describing Franco's performance...
Global Information