Philosophical problem about the starting point of knowledge
Part of a series on
Pyrrhonism
Pyrrhonists
Pyrrho
Timon of Phlius
Aenesidemus
Agrippa the Skeptic
Sextus Empiricus
Concepts
Ataraxia
Acatalepsy
Adiaphora
Aporia
Dogma
Epoché
Similar philosophies
Empiric school
Epilogism
Academic skepticism
Modern influence
Münchhausen trilemma
Benson Mates
Robert Fogelin
Philosophy portal
v
t
e
In the field of epistemology, the problem of the criterion is an issue regarding the starting point of knowledge. This is a separate and more fundamental issue than the regress argument found in discussions on justification of knowledge.[1]
In Western philosophy the earliest surviving documentation of the problem of the criterion is in the works of the Pyrrhonist philosopher Sextus Empiricus.[1] In Outlines of Pyrrhonism Sextus Empiricus demonstrated that no criterion of truth had been established, contrary to the position of dogmatists such as the Stoics and their doctrine of katalepsis.[2] In this Sextus was repeating or building upon earlier Pyrrhonist arguments about the problem of the criterion, as Pyrrho, the founder of Pyrrhonism, had declared that "neither our sense-perceptions nor our doxai (views, theories, beliefs) tell us the truth or lie.[3]
American philosopher Roderick Chisholm in his Theory of Knowledge details the problem of the criterion with two sets of questions:
What do we know? or What is the extent of our knowledge?
How do we know? or What is the criterion for deciding whether we have knowledge in any particular case?
An answer to either set of questions will allow us to devise a means of answering the other. Answering the former question set first is called particularism, whereas answering the latter set first is called methodism. A third solution is skepticism, which proclaims that since one cannot have an answer to the first set of questions without first answering the second set, and one cannot hope to answer the second set of questions without first knowing the answers to the first set, we are, therefore, unable to answer either. This has the result of us being unable to justify any of our beliefs.[citation needed]
Particularist theories organize things already known and attempt to use these particulars of knowledge to find a method of how we know, thus answering the second question set. Methodist theories propose an answer to question set two and proceed to use this to establish what we, in fact, know. Classical empiricism embraces the methodist approach.[citation needed]
^ ab"Problem of the criterion". Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
^Sextus Empiricus Outlines of Pyrrhonism Book II Chapters 4-9
^Beckwith, Christopher I. (2015). Greek Buddha: Pyrrho's Encounter with Early Buddhism in Central Asia(PDF). Princeton University Press. pp. 22–23. ISBN 9781400866328.
and 24 Related for: Problem of the criterion information
In the field of epistemology, theproblemofthecriterion is an issue regarding the starting point of knowledge. This is a separate and more fundamental...
over the rational numbers Euler's criterion, in number theory concerning primes Problemofthecriterion, in epistemology, an issue regarding the starting...
demarcation as a major problemofthe philosophy of science. Popper articulates theproblemof demarcation as: Theproblemof finding a criterion which would enable...
a problem since antiquity, American philosopher Roderick Chisholm in his Theory of Knowledge details theproblemofthecriterion with two sets of questions:...
nonetheless does exist. 'Theproblemof demarcation' is an expression introduced by Karl Popper to refer to 'theproblemof finding a criterion which would enable...
Thecriterionof dissimilarity (often used as a shorthand for criterionof double dissimilarity; it is also called criterionof discontinuity, originality...
verification, and as in theproblemofthecriterion, the reliability of these tools is disputed. Understanding a philosophy's criteria of truth is fundamental...
Fumerton, Richard (25 September 2008). "TheProblemoftheCriterion". The Oxford Handbook of Skepticism. Archived from the original on 2 June 2022. Retrieved...
In statistics, the Bayesian information criterion (BIC) or Schwarz information criterion (also SIC, SBC, SBIC) is a criterion for model selection among...
ask the question "What do we know?" before asking "How do we know?" The term appears in Roderick Chisholm's "TheProblemoftheCriterion", and in the work...
the Kelly criterion (or Kelly strategy or Kelly bet) is a formula for sizing a bet. The Kelly bet size is found by maximizing the expected value of the...
Chisholm on theProblemoftheCriterion Fumerton 2008, pp. 34–36 Stroll 2023, § The Origins of Knowledge, § Analytic Epistemology Lehrer 2015, 1. The Analysis...
debate in legal theory Imputation (law) Mistake of law Problemofthecriterion rule-following paradox rules of inference Secret law Qualified immunity Zero...
"ProblemoftheCriterion". Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Retrieved 28 May 2022. Fumerton, Richard (25 September 2008). "TheProblemofthe Criterion"...
have the Duhem problem because it is a logical criterion. Experimental research has the Duhem problem and other problems, such as theproblemof induction...
also represented within the regress argument, is closely related to theproblemofthecriterion and is a constituent ofthe Münchhausen trilemma. Illustrious...
selection is the task of selecting a model from among various candidates on the basis of performance criterion to choose the best one. In the context of machine...
The theta-criterion (also named θ-criterion) is a constraint on x-bar theory that was first proposed by Noam Chomsky (1981) as a rule within the system...
optimisation) or mathematical programming is the selection of a best element, with regard to some criterion, from some set of available alternatives. It is generally...
Iowa: The McGraw-Hill. pp. 3–4. ISBN 9780078117022. OCLC 716069710. Sankey, Howard (2010). "Witchcraft, Relativism and theProblemoftheCriterion". Erkenntnis...