For other uses, see Invisible hand (disambiguation).
Concept in economics
Part of a series on
Capitalism
Concepts
Austerity
Business
Business cycle
Businessperson
Capital
Capital accumulation
Capital markets
Company
Corporation
Competitive markets
Economic interventionism
Economic liberalism
Economic surplus
Entrepreneurship
Fictitious capital
Financial market
Free price system
Free market
Goods and services
Investor
Invisible hand
Visible hand
Liberalization
Marginalism
Money
Private property
Privatization
Profit
Rent seeking
Supply and demand
Surplus value
Value
Wage labour
Economic systems
Anglo-Saxon
Authoritarian
Corporate
Dirigist
Free-market
Humanistic
Laissez-faire
Liberal
Libertarian
Market
Mercantilist
Mixed
Monopoly
National
Neoliberal
Nordic
Private
Raw
Regulated market
Regulatory
Rhine
Social
State
State-sponsored
Welfare
Economic theories
American
Austrian
Chartalism
MMT
Chicago
Classical
Institutional
Keynesian
Neo-
New
Post-
Market monetarism
Critique of political economy
Critique of work
Marxist
Monetarist
Neoclassical
New institutional
Supply-side
Origins
Age of Enlightenment
Capitalism and Islam
Commercial Revolution
Feudalism
Industrial Revolution
Mercantilism
Primitive accumulation
Physiocracy
Simple commodity production
Development
Advanced
Consumer
Community
Corporate
Crony
Finance
Global
Illiberal
Late
Marxist
Merchant
Progressive
Rentier
State monopoly
Technological
People
Smith
Mill
Ricardo
Malthus
Say
Marx
Friedman
Hayek
Keynes
Marshall
Pareto
Walras
von Mises
Rand
Rothbard
Schumpeter
Veblen
Weber
Coase
Related topics
Anti-capitalism
Capitalist propaganda
Capitalist realism
Capitalist state
Consumerism
Crisis theory
Criticism of capitalism
Critique of political economy
Critique of work
Cronyism
Culture of capitalism
Evergreening
Exploitation of labour
Globalization
History
History of theory
Market economy
Periodizations of capitalism
Perspectives on capitalism
Post-capitalism
Speculation
Spontaneous order
Venture philanthropy
Wage slavery
Ideologies
Anarcho
Authoritarian
Classical liberalism
Democratic
Dirigisme
Eco
Humanistic
Inclusive
Liberal
Liberalism
Libertarian
Neo
Neoliberalism
Objectivism
Ordoliberalism
Privatism
Right-libertarianism
Third Way
Capitalism portal
Business portal
v
t
e
Part of a series on
Liberalism
Schools
Classical
Conservative
Cultural
Democratic
Feminist
Equity
Green
Internationalist
Muscular
National
Neo
Ordo
Radical
Religious
Christian
Catholic
Islamic
Jewish
Secular
Social
Techno
Third Way
Principles
Consent of the governed
Due process
Democracy
Economic liberalism
Economic globalization
Equality
Gender
Legal
Federalism
Freedom
Economic
Market
Trade
Press
Religion
Speech
Harm principle
Internationalism
Invisible hand
Labor theory of property
Laissez-faire
Liberty
Negative
Positive
Limited government
Market economy
Natural monopoly
Open society
Permissive society
Popular sovereignty
Property
Private
Public
Rights
Civil and political
Natural and legal
To own property
To bear arms
Rule of law
Secularism
Secular humanism
Separation of church and state
Separation of powers
Social contract
Social justice
Social services
Welfare state
State of nature
History
Age of Enlightenment
List of liberal theorists (contributions to liberal theory)
Philosophers
Milton
Locke
Spinoza
Montesquieu
Voltaire
Rousseau
Smith
Kant
Turgot
Burke
Priestley
Paine
Beccaria
Condorcet
Bentham
Korais
De Gouges
Wollstonecraft
Staël
Say
Humboldt
Constant
Ricardo
Guizot
List
Bastiat
Martineau
Emerson
Tocqueville
Mill
Spencer
Arnold
Acton
Weber
Hobhouse
Croce
Cassirer
Mises
Ortega
Keynes
Collingwood
Čapek
Hu
Hayek
Popper
Aron
Berlin
Friedman
Rawls
Sen
Nozick
Kymlicka
Badawi
Politicians
Jefferson
Kołłątaj
Madison
Artigas
Bolívar
Broglie
Lamartine
Macaulay
Kossuth
Deák
Cobden
Mazzini
Juárez
Lincoln
Gladstone
Cavour
Sarmiento
Mommsen
Naoroji
Itagaki
Levski
Kemal
Deakin
Milyukov
Lloyd George
Venizelos
Ståhlberg
Gokhale
Rathenau
Madero
Einaudi
King
Roosevelt
Pearson
Ohlin
Kennedy
Jenkins
Organizations
Africa Liberal Network
Alliance of Liberals and Democrats for Europe
Alliance of Liberals and Democrats for Europe Party
Arab Liberal Federation
Council of Asian Liberals and Democrats
European Democratic Party
European Liberal Youth
International Alliance of Libertarian Parties
International Federation of Liberal Youth
Liberal International
Liberal Network for Latin America
Liberal parties
Liberal South East European Network
Regional variants
Europe
Latin America
Albania
Armenia
Australia
Austria
Belgium
Bolivia
Brazil
Bulgaria
Canada
Chile
China
Hong Kong
Colombia
Costa Rica
Croatia
Cuba
Cyprus
Czechia
Denmark
Ecuador
Egypt
Estonia
Finland
France
Georgia
Germany
Greece
Venizelism
Honduras
Hungary
Iceland
India
Iran
Israel
Italy
Liberism
Japan
Latvia
Lithuania
Luxembourg
Mexico
Moldova
Montenegro
Netherlands
New Zealand
Nicaragua
Nigeria
North Macedonia
Norway
Panama
Paraguay
Peru
Philippines
Poland
Cracovian
Portugal
Romania
Russia
Senegal
Serbia
Slovakia
Slovenia
South Africa
South Korea
Spain
Sweden
Switzerland
Taiwan
Thailand
Tunisia
Turkey
Ukraine
United Kingdom
Cobdenism
Gladstonian
Manchester
Whiggism
United States
Arizona School
Classical
Jeffersonian
Modern
Uruguay
Venezuela
Zimbabwe
Related topics
Anti-authoritarianism
Anti-communism
Bias in American academia
Bias in the media
Capitalism
Democratic
Centrism
Radical centrism
Economic freedom
Egalitarianism
Empiricism
Humanism
Individualism
Anarchist
Land value tax
Libertarianism
Left
Right
Pirate Party
Sexually liberal feminism
Utilitarianism
Liberalism portal
Politics portal
v
t
e
The invisible hand is a metaphor inspired by the Scottish moral philosopher Adam Smith that describes the incentives which free markets often create for self-interested people to act in the public interest.[1] Smith originally mentioned the term only in specific examples. It is used once in his Theory of Moral Sentiments when discussing the concentration of wealth. More famously, it is also used once in his Wealth of Nations, when arguing that international traders can be trusted if the incentives are right, often making it unnecessary for governments to intervene.
Twentieth century economists such as Paul Samuelson popularized the use of the term to refer more generally to unintended greater social impacts brought about by individuals acting in their own self-interest.[2][3] The idea of trade and market exchange perfectly channeling self-interest toward socially desirable ends is a central justification for newer versions of the laissez-faire economic philosophy which lie behind neoclassical economics.[4]
Smith himself described the term "invisible hand" as rhetorical and unscientific, and did not use it to refer to any general principle of economics. His argumentation against government interventions into markets were based on specific cases and were not absolute.[5] While Smith's arguments against government management of the economy were very popular, the ideas were not new. Smith himself cites earlier enlightenment thinkers such as Bernard Mandeville.[6][7][8] Smith's invisible hand argumentation may have also been influenced by Richard Cantillon and his model of the isolated estate.[9]
Because of the modern use of this term to refer to a key neoclassical assumption, a central disagreement between economic ideologies is sometimes viewed as a disagreement about how well the "invisible hand" works. For example, it is argued that tendencies that were nascent during Smith's lifetime, such as large-scale industry, finance, and advertising, now reduce its effectiveness.[10]
^Grampp, William D. (June 2000). "What Did Smith Mean by the Invisible Hand?". Journal of Political Economy. 108 (3). University of Chicago Press: 441–465. doi:10.1086/262125. S2CID 154797179.
^Rothschild, Emma (1994). "Adam Smith and the Invisible Hand". The American Economic Review. 84 (2): 319–322. JSTOR 2117851.
^Sen, Amartya. Introduction. The Theory of Moral Sentiments. By Adam Smith. 6th ed. 1790. New York: Penguin, 2009. vii–xxix.
^Slater, D. & Tonkiss, F. (2001). Market Society: Markets and Modern Social Theory. Cambridge: Polity Press, pp. 54–5
^Kennedy, Gavin (2010). "Paul Samuelson and the Invention of the Modern Economics of the Invisible Hand". History of Economic Ideas. 18 (3). Accademia Editoriale: 105–119. JSTOR 23724554. Modern attributions to Adam Smith's use of the Invisible-Hand metaphor are at variance with Smith's teachings on the use and role of metaphors, and, therefore, they misread his contributions in moral philosophy and his political economy.
^Class, Master (November 8, 2020). "What Is the Invisible Hand in Economics?". www.masterclass.com. MasterClass. Retrieved February 17, 2021. Eighteenth-century economist Adam Smith developed the concept of the Invisible Hand, which became one of the cornerstone concepts of a free market economic system.
^Cite error: The named reference :1 was invoked but never defined (see the help page).
^Cite error: The named reference :2 was invoked but never defined (see the help page).
^Thornton, Mark. "Cantillon and the Invisible Hand". Quarterly Journal of Austrian Economics, Vol. 12, No. 2 (2009) pp. 27–46.
^Olsen, James Stewart. Encyclopedia of the Industrial Revolution. Greenwood Publishing Group, 2002. pp. 153–154
The invisiblehand is a metaphor inspired by the Scottish moral philosopher Adam Smith that describes the incentives which free markets often create for...
Landscape with InvisibleHand is a 2023 American science fiction film written and directed by Cory Finley, based on the 2017 novel of the same name by...
InvisibleHands may refer to: "InvisibleHands" (song), a 1983 song by Kim Carnes InvisibleHands (novel), by Norwegian author Stig Sæterbakken Invisible...
The Other InvisibleHand is a non-fiction book written by the economist Julian Le Grand. The primary focus of his book is increasing taxpayer sovereignty...
third book. Smith used the term "the invisiblehand" in "History of Astronomy" referring to "the invisiblehand of Jupiter", and once in each of his The...
frontline capital ship at the Battle of Coruscant. A modified variant, the InvisibleHand, serves as the command ship for Count Dooku and General Grievous. In...
society through profit-driven production of goods and services. An "invisiblehand" directed individuals and firms to work toward the public good as an...
Smith's invisiblehand: individuals and firms, in the pursuit of their self-interest, are not necessarily, or in general, led as if by an invisiblehand, to...
Television Award. Blackk made his film debut in Cory Finley's Landscape with InvisibleHand, which was released in August 2023; he later appeared in Story Ave,...
from Foreign Countries of such Goods as can be Produced at Home". The "invisiblehand" is a frequently referenced theme from the book, although it is specifically...
for Economic Education. Retrieved 28 November 2019. Paul Cantor, The InvisibleHand in Popular Culture: Liberty Vs. Authority in American Film and TV, University...
Mittermaier. “Free-Market Dogmatism and Pragmatism.” In The Hand Behind the InvisibleHand: Dogmatic and Pragmatic Views on Free Markets and the State...
argues that in the nineteenth century, Adam Smith's invisiblehand was supplanted by the "visible hand" of middle management, which became "the most powerful...
economic actions of individuals are largely based on self-interest (invisiblehand) and that allowing them to act without any restrictions will produce...
Junk (2017). He also authored the plays The Who & The What and The InvisibleHand. His plays have been produced on Broadway, off-Broadway, and in London...
theory looks at three concepts: rational actors, self interest and the invisiblehand. Rationality can be used as an assumption for the behaviour of individuals...
transformation. Jonathan Mahler of The New York Times notes in his article The InvisibleHand Behind Harper Lee's 'To Kill a Mockingbird' that Ms. Hohoff, at the...
market Global financial crisis in September 2008 Humanistic economics Invisiblehand Late capitalism Le Livre noir du capitalisme Market socialism Perspectives...
Hollywood 'Babylon' With Emma Stone". Deadline Hollywood. "Landscape with InvisibleHand - Full Cast & Crew". TV Guide. Retrieved March 5, 2024. Thompson, Jaden...