This article is about analysis and criticism of the actions and policies of states governed by communist parties, usually Marxist–Leninist or some national variation thereof, not communist philosophy or political theory. For criticism of communism as an ideology, see Criticism of Marxism. For criticism of socialism in general, see Criticism of socialism.
Part of a series on
Communist parties
Africa
Algeria
Benin
Botswana
Burkina Faso
Egypt
Eswatini
Ivory Coast
Kenya
Lesotho
Libya
Madagascar
Namibia
Morocco
Réunion
Senegal
South Africa
EFF
SACP
South Sudan
Sudan
Togo
Tunisia
Americas
Argentina
PCA
PCCE
PCRA
Bolivia
Brazil
PCdoB
PCB
PCO
PCR
PSTU
Canada
CL
CPC
CPC-ML
Chile
PCCh
PC(AP)
Colombia
PCC
PC de C (M–L)
Cuba
Dominican Republic
Ecuador
PCE
PCMLE
Mexico
PC
PPS
PPSM
PCMML
Panama
PPP
PC(ml)P
Paraguay
Peru
PCP
PCdelP–PR
PL
Uruguay
United States
CPUSA
WWP
PSL
RCPUSA
PLP
Venezuela
PCV
PCMLV
Asia
Bahrain
Bangladesh
CPB
WPB
Bhutan
Burma
China (PRC)
India
CPI
CPI(M)
CPI-ML(L)
CPI(Mst)
SUCI(C)
MCPM
AIFB
RSP
Iran
CPI
Tudeh
Toufan
Iraq
Israel
Japan
Jordan
Kazakhstan
CPK
PPK
Kyrgyzstan
Laos
Lebanon
Nepal
CPN (UML)
CPN (MC)
CPN (US)
NWPP
RaJaMo
North Korea
Pakistan
Palestine
Philippines
CPP
PKP-1930
Sri Lanka
CPSL
JVP
FLSP
Syria
SCP (Bakdash)
SCP (Unified)
Tajikistan
Vietnam
Former parties
Cambodia
KPRP
CPK
Indonesia
Korea
Malaya and Singapore
Marxist–Leninist
Revolutionary Faction
Philippines
Saudi Arabia
Sarawak
Taiwan
Thailand
Europe
Albania
Armenia
Austria
KPÖ
PdA
KI
Azerbaijan
Belarus
Belgium
KP
PC
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Bulgaria
KPB
SKB
Croatia
Cyprus
Czech Republic
Denmark
DKP
KP
APK
Estonia
Finland
France
PCF
PCOF
PRCF
PCRF
Georgia
Germany
KPD
DKP
MLPD
Greece
ΚΚΕ
ΚΟΕ
Anasintaxi
Hungary
Munkáspárt
Munkáspárt 2006
Ireland
CPI
WPI
Italy
PC
PRC
Latvia
Lithuania
Luxembourg
Malta
Moldova
Netherlands
Norway
NKP
MLGR
R
Poland
Portugal
PCP
PCTP
Romania
Russia
KR
CPRF
PDP
RCWP-CPSU
RMP
RULF
San Marino
Serbia
Slovakia
Spain
PCE
CC
PCPE
PCE (M–L)
PCTE
Sweden
KP
SKP
Switzerland
Communist Party (Switzerland)
PdA
Turkey
DHKP/C
EMEP
HTKP
KDH/L
KKP
TKP
MKP
MLKP
TDKP
TKEP
TKEP/L
TKIP
TKP/ML
Ukraine
KPU
SKU
United Kingdom
CPB
CPB-ML
CPGB-ML
CPGB-PCC
CPS
NCPB
RCG
RCP
RCPB-ML
Former parties
Albania
Czechoslovakia
East Germany
Italy
Netherlands
Poland
Romania
Soviet Union
Turkey
United Kingdom
West Germany
Yugoslavia
Oceania
Australia
CPA
CPA(ML)
Socialist Alliance
Socialist Alternative
Victorian Socialists
New Zealand
CL
OMU
SPA
Former parties
Australia
Communist Alliance
CPA
DSP
RSP
Victorian Socialist Party
New Zealand
CPNZ
SUP
CL
Related topics
Central committee
Communism (history)
Criticism of rule
List of communist parties
Democratic centralism
General Secretary
Marxism–Leninism
Politburo
Vanguardism
Communism portal
v
t
e
History of communist states
Current communist states
China (PRC)
Cuba
Laos
Korea (DPRK)
Vietnam
Previous communist states
Afghanistan
Albania
Angola
Benin
Bulgaria
Congo
Czechoslovakia
Ethiopia
Germany (GDR)
Grenada
Hungary
Kampuchea
Mongolia
Mozambique
Poland
Romania
Somalia
Soviet Union
Tuva
Yemen (PDRY)
Yugoslavia
Post-Soviet states
Abkhazia
Armenia
Azerbaijan
Belarus
Estonia
Georgia
Kazakhstan
Kyrgyzstan
Latvia
Lithuania
Moldova
Russia
South Ossetia
Tajikistan
Transnistria
Turkmenistan
Ukraine
Uzbekistan
Communism portal
v
t
e
The actions by governments of communist states have been subject to criticism across the political spectrum.[1] Communist party rule has been especially criticized by anti-communists and right-wing critics, but also by other socialists such as anarchists, democratic socialists, libertarian socialists, orthodox Marxists, and Trotskyist communists. Ruling communist parties have also been challenged by domestic dissent.[2] According to the critics, rule by communist parties has often led to totalitarianism, political repression, restrictions of human rights, poor economic performance, and cultural and artistic censorship.[1][3]
Several authors noted gaps between official policies of equality and economic justice and the reality of the emergence of a new class in communist countries which thrived at the expense of the remaining population. In Central and Eastern Europe, the works of dissidents Václav Havel and Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn gained international prominence, as did the works of disillusioned ex-communists such as Milovan Đilas, who condemned the new class or nomenklatura system that had emerged under communist party rule.[4][5][6] Major criticism also comes from the anti-Stalinist left and other socialists.[7][8][9][10] Its socio-economic nature has been much debated, varyingly being labelled a form of bureaucratic collectivism, state capitalism, state socialism, or a totally unique mode of production.[11][12][13][14]
Communist party rule has been criticized as authoritarian or totalitarian for suppressing and killing political dissidents and social classes (so-called "enemies of the people"), religious persecution, ethnic cleansing, forced collectivization, and use of forced labor in concentration camps. Communist party rule has also been accused of genocidal acts in Cambodia, China, Poland and Ukraine, although there is scholarly dispute regarding the Holodomor's classification as genocide.[15] Especially in the West, criticism of communist rule has also been grounded in criticism of socialism, by economists such as Friedrich Hayek and Milton Friedman, who argued that the state ownership and planned economy characteristic of Soviet-style communist rule were responsible for economic stagnation and shortage economies, providing few incentives for individuals to improve productivity and engage in entrepreneurship.[16][17][18][19][20] Anti-Stalinist left and other left-wing critics see it as an example of state capitalism[21][22] and have referred to it as a "red fascism" contrary to left-wing politics.[23][24][25] Other leftists, including Marxist–Leninists, criticize it for its repressive state actions while recognizing certain advancements such as egalitarian achievements and modernization under such states.[26][27] Counter-criticism is diverse, including the view it presents a biased or exaggerated anti-communist narrative. Some academics propose a more nuanced analysis of communist party rule.[28][29]
Excess deaths under communist party rule have been discussed as part of a critical analysis of communist party rule. According to Klas-Göran Karlsson, discussion of the number of victims of communist party rule has been "extremely extensive and ideologically biased."[30] Any attempt to estimate a total number of killings under communist party rule depends greatly on definitions,[31] ranging from a low of 10–20 million to as high as 148 million.[32][33] The criticism of some of the estimates are mostly focused on three aspects, namely that (i) the estimates are based on sparse and incomplete data when significant errors are inevitable; (ii) the figures are skewed to higher possible values; and (iii) those dying at war and victims of civil wars, Holodomor and other famines under communist party rule should not be counted.[34][35][36][37][38][39] Others have argued that, while certain estimates may not be accurate, "quibbling about numbers is unseemly. What matters is that many, many people were killed by communist regimes."[29] Right-wing commentators argue that these excess deaths and killings are an indictment of communism,[40][41][42] while opponents of this view, including members of the political left, argue that these killings were aberrations caused by specific authoritarian regimes instead of communism, and point to mass deaths that they claim were caused by capitalism and anti-communism as a counterpoint to communist killings.[29][41][43]
^ ab"Criticisms of Communist Party Rule". Philosophybasics. Archived from the original on 11 March 2018. Retrieved 10 March 2018.
^Pollack, Detlef; Wielgohs, Jan. "Dissent and Opposition in Communist Eastern Europe" (PDF). European University Viadrina. Archived (PDF) from the original on 11 March 2018. Retrieved 10 March 2018.
^Krieger, Joel (2001). "Communist Party States". The Oxford Companion to Politics of the World (2 ed.). Oxford Reference. doi:10.1093/acref/9780195117394.001.0001. hdl:1721.1/141579. ISBN 9780195117394. Archived from the original on 11 March 2018. Retrieved 10 March 2018.
^Đilas, Milovan (1983) [1957]. The New Class: An Analysis of the Communist System (paperback ed.). San Diego: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich. ISBN 0-15-665489-X.
^Đilas, Milovan (1969). The Unperfect Society: Beyond the New Class. Translated by Cooke, Dorian. New York City: Harcourt, Brace & World. ISBN 0-15-693125-7.
^Đilas, Milovan (1998). Fall of the New Class: A History of Communism's Self-Destruction (hardcover ed.). Alfred A. Knopf. ISBN 0-679-43325-2.
^Chomsky, Noam (Spring/Summer 1986). "The Soviet Union Versus Socialism." Our Generation. Retrieved 10 June 2020 – via Chomsky.info.
^Howard, M. C.; King J. E. King (2001). "'State Capitalism' in the Soviet Union". History of Economics Review. 34 (1): 110–126. doi:10.1080/10370196.2001.11733360.
^Wolff, Richard D. (27 June 2015). "Socialism Means Abolishing the Distinction Between Bosses and Employees" Archived 2018-03-11 at the Wayback Machine. Truthout. Retrieved 29 January 2020.
^Robinson, Nathan J. (28 October 2017). "How to Be a Socialist without Being an Apologist for the Atrocities of Communist Regimes". Current Affairs. Retrieved 8 September 2020.
^Andrai, Charles F. (1994). Comparative Political Systems: Policy Performance and Social Change. Armonk, New York: M. E. Sharpe. p. 140.
^Sandle 1999, pp. 265–266.
^Morgan, W. John (2001). "Marxism–Leninism: The Ideology of Twentieth-Century Communism". In Wright, James D. (ed.). International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences (2nd ed.). Oxford: Elsevier. pp. 657–662.
^Smith, S. A. (2014). The Oxford Handbook of the History of Communism. Oxford: Oxford University Press. p. 126. ISBN 9780191667527. The 1936 Constitution described the Soviet Union for the first time as a 'socialist society', rhetorically fulfilling the aim of building socialism in one country, as Stalin had promised.
^Sawicky, Nicholas D. (20 December 2013). The Holodomor: Genocide and National Identity (Education and Human Development Master's Theses). The College at Brockport: State University of New York. Retrieved 6 October 2020 – via Digital Commons. Scholars also disagree over what role the Soviet Union played in the tragedy. Some scholars point to Stalin as the mastermind behind the famine, due to his hatred of Ukrainians (Hosking, 1987). Others assert that Stalin did not actively cause the famine, but he knew about it and did nothing to stop it (Moore, 2012). Still other scholars argue that the famine was just an effect of the Soviet Union's push for rapid industrialization and a by-product of that was the destruction of the peasant way of life (Fischer, 1935). The final school of thought argues that the Holodomor was caused by factors beyond the control of the Soviet Union and Stalin took measures to reduce the effects of the famine on the Ukrainian people (Davies & Wheatcroft, 2006).
^Von Mises, Ludwig (1990). Economic calculation in the Socialist Commonwealth(PDF). Mises Institute. Archived (PDF) from the original on 13 September 2019. Retrieved 11 November 2019.
^Hayek, Friedrich (1935). "The Nature and History of the Problem"; "The Present State of the Debate". Collectivist Economic Planning. pp. 1–40, 201–243.
^Durlauf, Steven N.; Blume, Lawrence E., ed. (1987). The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics Online. Palgrave Macmillan. Retrieved 2 February 2013. doi:10.1057/9780230226203.1570.
^Biddle, Jeff; Samuels, Warren; Davis, John (2006). A Companion to the History of Economic Thought, Wiley-Blackwell. p. 319. "What became known as the socialist calculation debate started when von Mises (1935 [1920]) launched a critique of socialism".
^Levy, David M.; Peart, Sandra J. (2008). "Socialist calculation debate". The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics (Second ed.). Palgrave Macmillan. ISBN 978-0333786765.
^Cliff, Tony (1996). State Capitalism in Russia(PDF). Retrieved 6 October 2020 – via Marxists Internet Archive.
^Alami, Ilias; Dixon, Adam D. (January 2020). "State Capitalism(s) Redux? Theories, Tensions, Controversies". Competition & Change. 24 (1): 70–94. doi:10.1177/1024529419881949. ISSN 1024-5294. S2CID 211422892.
^Voline (1995). "Red Fascism". Itinéraire (13). Translated by Sharkey, Paul. Paris. Retrieved 6 October 2020 – via The Anarchist Library. First published in the July 1934 edition of Ce qu'il faut dire (Brussels).
^Meyer, Gerald (Summer 2003). "Anarchism, Marxism and the Collapse of the Soviet Union". Science & Society. 67 (2): 218–221. doi:10.1521/siso.67.2.218.21187. ISSN 0036-8237. JSTOR 40404072.
^Tamblyn, Nathan (April 2019). "The Common Ground of Law and Anarchism". Liverpool Law Review. 40 (1): 65–78. doi:10.1007/s10991-019-09223-1. hdl:10871/36939. ISSN 1572-8625. S2CID 155131683.
^Cite error: The named reference Parenti 1997 was invoked but never defined (see the help page).
^Milne, Seumas (16 February 2006). "Communism may be dead, but clearly not dead enough". The Guardian. Retrieved 18 April 2020. The dominant account gives no sense of how communist regimes renewed themselves after 1956 or why western leaders feared they might overtake the capitalist world well into the 1960s. For all its brutalities and failures, communism in the Soviet Union, eastern Europe and elsewhere delivered rapid industrialisation, mass education, job security and huge advances in social and gender equality.
^Ghodsee, Kristen (Fall 2014). "A Tale of 'Two Totalitarianisms': The Crisis of Capitalism and the Historical Memory of Communism" (PDF). History of the Present: A Journal of Critical History. 4 (2): 115–142. doi:10.5406/historypresent.4.2.0115. JSTOR 10.5406/historypresent.4.2.0115.
^ abcGhodsee, Kristen; Sehon, Scott; Dresser, Sam, eds. (22 March 2018). "The merits of taking an anti-anti-communism stance". Aeon. Archived from the original on 1 April 2022. Retrieved 12 August 2021.
^Karlsson, Klas-Göran; Schoenhals, Michael (2008). Crimes Against Humanity under Communist Regimes. Forum for Living History. ISBN 9789197748728.
^Dallin, Alexander (2000). "Reviewed Work(s): The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, Repression by Stéphane Courtois, Nicolas Werth, Jean-Louis Panné, Andrzej Paczkowski, Karel Bartošek, Jean-Louis Margolin, Jonathan Murphy and Mark Kramer". Slavic Review. 59 (4): 882‒883. doi:10.2307/2697429. JSTOR 2697429.
^Valentino 2005, pp. 75, 91, 275.
^"Reevaluating China's Democide to 73,000,000". 24 November 2008.
^Harff, Barbara (1996). "Death by Government by R. J. Rummel". The Journal of Interdisciplinary History. 27 (1): 117–119. doi:10.2307/206491. JSTOR 206491.
^Kuromiya, Hiroaki (2001). "Review Article: Communism and Terror. Reviewed Work(s): The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, and Repression by Stephane Courtois; Reflections on a Ravaged Century by Robert Conquest". Journal of Contemporary History. 36 (1): 191–201. doi:10.1177/002200940103600110. JSTOR 261138. S2CID 49573923.
^Paczkowski, Andrzej (2001). "The Storm Over the Black Book". The Wilson Quarterly. 25 (2): 28–34. JSTOR 40260182.
^Weiner, Amir (2002). "Review. Reviewed Work: The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, Repression by Stéphane Courtois, Nicolas Werth, Jean-Louis Panné, Andrzej Paczkowski, Karel Bartošek, Jean-Louis Margolin, Jonathan Murphy, Mark Kramer". Journal of Interdisciplinary History. 32 (3): 450–452. doi:10.1162/002219502753364263. JSTOR 3656222. S2CID 142217169.
^Dulić, Tomislav (2004). "Tito's Slaughterhouse: A Critical Analysis of Rummel's Work on Democide". Journal of Peace Research. 41 (1): 85–102. doi:10.1177/0022343304040051. JSTOR 4149657. S2CID 145120734.
^Harff, Barbara (2017). "The Comparative Analysis of Mass Atrocities and Genocide" (PDF). In Gleditsch, N. P. (ed.). R.J. Rummel: An Assessment of His Many Contributions. SpringerBriefs on Pioneers in Science and Practice. Vol. 37. pp. 111–129. doi:10.1007/978-3-319-54463-2_12. ISBN 9783319544632.
^Piereson, James. "Socialism as a hate crime". newcriterion.com. Retrieved 22 October 2021.
^ abEngel-Di Mauro, Salvatore; et al. (4 May 2021). "Anti-Communism and the Hundreds of Millions of Victims of Capitalism". Capitalism Nature Socialism. 32 (1): 1–17. doi:10.1080/10455752.2021.1875603.
^Satter, David (6 November 2017). "100 Years of Communism—and 100 Million Dead". The Wall Street Journal. ISSN 0099-9660. Retrieved 22 October 2021.
^Bevins, Vincent (2020). The Jakarta Method: Washington's Anticommunist Crusade and the Mass Murder Program that Shaped Our World. PublicAffairs. p. 240. ISBN 978-1541742406. ... we do not live in a world directly constructed by Stalin's purges or mass starvation under Pol Pot. Those states are gone. Even Mao's Great Leap Forward was quickly abandoned and rejected by the Chinese Communist Party, though the party is still very much around. We do, however, live in a world built partly by US-backed Cold War violence. ... Washington's anticommunist crusade, with Indonesia as the apex of its murderous violence against civilians, deeply shaped the world we live in now ... .
and 23 Related for: Criticism of communist party rule information
actions by governments ofcommunist states have been subject to criticism across the political spectrum. Communistpartyrule has been especially criticized...
thereof are some of the symbols adopted by communist movements, governments, and parties worldwide. A tradition of including communist symbolism in socialist-style...
title of General Secretary or First Secretary is commonly used for the leaders of most communistparties. When a communistparty is the ruling partyof a...
the French CommunistParty won more votes than any other party in the French national elections.[citation needed] After 1956, their share of the vote gradually...
state of Kerala has a strong presence ofcommunist politics. Today, the two largest communistparties in Kerala politics are the CommunistPartyof India...
countries instead. Their criticism was shared by the Indian revolutionary M.N. Roy, who attended as a delegate of the CommunistPartyof Mexico. The congress...
leading role of the party is a constitutional principle most common in communist states. It holds that the ruling party leads the state by virtue of being the...
A communist state, also known as a Marxist–Leninist state, is a one-party state that is administered and governed by a communistparty guided by Marxism–Leninism...
the CommunistPartyof Italy. The teachings of Jesus are frequently described as communist by religious Christian communists and other communists. Acts...
some of the indigenous groups of Siberia and the Russian far east (such as the Nivkh) to be primitive communist in nature. Criticismof the idea of primitive...
Sinha Jatindra Nath Das Manmath Nath Gupta The CommunistPartyof India, one of the major communistparty, which is still in existence, was formed on 26...
United States and the Soviet Union. Parties and groups that supported the CommunistPartyof China in their criticism against the new Soviet leadership...
The CommunistPartyof India (CPI) is the oldest communistparty in India. The CPI was founded in modern-day Kanpur on 26 December 1925. Although the CPI...
the Democratic People's Republic of Korea, continues to be a Jucheist state under the ruleof the Workers' Partyof Korea. In South Korea, the National...
themselves as communist (comunista) parties, movements, organizations, groups, etc. The oldest communistparty in Peru is the Peruvian CommunistParty (Partido...
of their countries. Communistparties that have attempted to pursue independent foreign and domestic policies that conflicted with the interests of the...
leadership is a distribution of power within an organizational structure. Collective leadership in China and Chinese CommunistParty (CCP) is generally considered...
and Marxism CriticismofcommunistpartyruleCriticismof socialism Transformation problem See M. C. Howard and J.E. King, 1992, A History of Marxian Economics:...
Criticismof communism may refer to: Criticismofcommunistpartyrule, which is criticismof the practical policies implemented by 20th century governments...
period ofcommunistrule. The Chinese CommunistParty emerged as the dominant political entity in mainland China following the Chinese Civil War of 1927–1949...
The Communist League (German: Bund der Kommunisten) was an international political party established on 1 June 1847 in London, England. The organisation...