Environmental audit privilege, or environmental privilege, in United States environmental law, is an evidentiary privilege created under state statute. The privilege protects the results of companies' internal environmental compliance audits from disclosure at trial, or in pretrial discovery.
The environmental audit privilege is meant to incentivize companies to evaluate their own compliance with environmental regulations.[1] Proponents of such laws further argue that it is necessary to encourage such self-evaluations, because regulatory agencies lack the resources to police all the polluters in their jurisdiction.[2]
Environmental audit privilege statutes have been promoted by the conservative American Legislative Exchange Council, which circulates a model statute known as the "Uniform State Environmental Audit Privilege Act".[1] However, most state environmental privilege laws are non-uniform, and vary greatly in their scope, exceptions and effect.[3]
The United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has been skeptical of state environmental audit privilege laws, and generally requires that states limit the privilege's effect so as not to interfere with federal investigations.[4] These concerns were heightened by the question of whether these laws would apply to state government agencies to which the EPA delegated its enforcement authority under federal law.[5] Accordingly, in the past, the EPA has used its statutory powers in the delegation of EPA enforcement authority to discourage states from adopting excessively powerful environmental audit privilege laws.[4]
Some states do not recognize environmental audit privilege, but do provide immunity from civil penalties for the results of internal compliance audits. These states include Minnesota, New Jersey, and Rhode Island.[6]
^Robin Morris Collin (2008). Battleground: Environment. p. 183. ISBN 0313082405.
^James B. Witkin (1999). Environmental aspects of real estate transactions: from brownfields to green buildings. American Bar Association.
^ abAmerican Law Institute-American Bar Association Committee on Continuing Professional Education (1998). Environmental and Toxic Tort Matters. p. 227.
^Christina Austin (1996). "State Environmental Audit Privilege Laws: Can EPA Still Access Environmental Audits in Federal Court?". Environmental Law. 26 (4): 1241–1261. JSTOR 43267549.
^"State Audit Privilege and Immunity Laws & Self-Disclosure Laws and Policies". United States Environmental Protection Agency. Retrieved 2017-11-23.
and 27 Related for: Environmental audit privilege information
financial audits. There are generally two different types of environmentalaudits: compliance audits and management systems audits. Compliance audits tend...
pollution and environmental emissions. Coors was not violating the Clean Air Act but was encouraged by the EnvironmentalAuditPrivilege and Voluntary...
covered by legal privilege. The FRC fined the company £1.95m for ethical failures after it tried to conceal evidence of involvement in the audit of the failed...
sales practices, consultancy services, tax payments, internal audit, external audit and executive compensation also, fall under the umbrella of finance...
organizations such as the Human Rights Campaign for being inefficient. One audit by the organization found that Twitter failed to act on 99 out of 100 of...
juristic person) has a legal name and has certain rights, protections, privileges, responsibilities, and liabilities in law, similar to those of a natural...
solutions could be made available. The published list contained two local privilege escalation vulnerabilities and three local denial of service attacks....
better use of environmental taxation, phase out agricultural subsidies and environmentally harmful tax breaks. In the Netherlands, audits are performed...
Reserve. TerraPass is audited according to guidelines established by the Center for Resource Solutions. The focus of the audit is to verify that TerraPass...
privilege escalation, many programs have been written or adapted to make use of privilege separation, privilege revocation and chrooting. Privilege separation...
2003 that Qatar Airways became the first airline to be audited under the new IATA operational audit programme, IOSA. The Qatar Airways Group —which included...
priority. The main instrument for safety is the IATA Operational Safety Audit (IOSA). IOSA has also been mandated at the state level by several countries...
that she took a consulting job at a cannabis company while her office was auditing Oregon's marijuana industry, which many considered to be a conflict of...
(British Columbia Social Credit Party) — influence peddling and abuse of privilege on timber licenses by Forest Minister Gracie's Finger (Social Credit Party)...
the growing consumer demand for responsible, sustainable clothing. EnvironmentalAudit Committee of the UK Parliament, "Fixing fashion: clothing consumption...
Municipality and Bornholm. On 1 January 2007, the municipality lost its county privileges and became part of the Capital Region of Denmark. Copenhagen Municipality...
Foreign Affairs. In the 1997–2001 Parliament he was a Member of the EnvironmentalAudit Select Committee and in January 2000 he received the Green Ribbon...
to the Games. Not being sanctioned does not automatically confer the privilege of an invitation" and that "this [case] may have a serious impact on the...
ranking first in three out of four major measured discipline fields. One privilege of student life at the University of Cambridge is the opportunity to attend...
The UK House of Commons Committee of Privileges inquiry into the matter referred on 21 April 2022 on the conduct of Boris Johnson concerns four specific...
themselves from a lawsuit." The government invoked the State Secrets Privilege and petitioned U.S. District Judge Philip Pro to disallow disclosure of...
authenticity & trustworthiness, non-repudiation, accountability and auditability." (Cherdantseva and Hilton, 2013) Information and information resource...
civile svizzero (Libro quinto: Diritto delle obbligazioni) SR 221.302 – Audit Supervision Act 2005 2007 Governs the accreditation and supervision auditors...
codifies and explains the function of the Royal Audit Authority. The Audit Authority is tasked with auditing the accounts of all departments and offices of...
April – BBC News reports that Johnston Carmichael, the accountants who audit the SNP's accounts, have resigned from the role, citing a their decision...